Once Upon a Book Club


Once upon a time, there was a group of women studying publishing in Edinburgh, Scotland. Neither of them was originally from the country, but they all had something in common: they had a fondness for romance novels. And so it happened, that when they crossed paths, it did not take long before a book club was formed.

The Proposal by Jasmine Guillory

For February we decided to go a little theme crazy. If you’ve looked closely at the cover of The Proposal you might have noticed the little illustrations of cocktails, cupcakes, and taco’s… Now, with this month being February. (Meaning: Valentines Day.) We went all out and decided a cover recreation was in order for book club day.

Once Upon a Book Club – FebruaryThe Proposal by Jasmine Guillory
Published by Berkley Books on October 30th 2018
Genres: Love & Romance
Pages: 327
Buy on Bol.comBuy on Book Depository

When someone asks you to spend your life with him, it shouldn't come as a surprise--or happen in front of 45,000 people.

When freelance writer Nikole Paterson goes to a Dodgers game with her actor boyfriend, his man bun, and his bros, the last thing she expects is a scoreboard proposal. Saying no isn't the hard part--they've only been dating for five months, and he can't even spell her name correctly. The hard part is having to face a stadium full of disappointed fans...

At the game with his sister, Carlos Ibarra comes to Nik's rescue and rushes her away from a camera crew. He's even there for her when the video goes viral and Nik's social media blows up--in a bad way. Nik knows that in the wilds of LA, a handsome doctor like Carlos can't be looking for anything serious, so she embarks on an epic rebound with him, filled with food, fun, and fantastic sex. But when their glorified hookups start breaking the rules, one of them has to be smart enough to put on the brakes...

Justine on the plot

In true feel-good-romance-fashion, Jasmine Guillory delivers the ultimate ‘meet cute’ to launch us into Carlos and Nik’s story. After their swift escape post-jumbotron fiasco, the two remain in touch and quickly develop a connection. Albeit sometimes a tad cheesy, the plot offers a surprisingly accurate portrayal of modern contemporary romance. While Nik and Carlos’ interactions are believable, they are constantly convincing themselves that neither wants a serious relationship. Instead, the two remain in the ambiguous ‘no-label’, ‘grey-area’, ‘friends-with-benefits’, whatever you want to call it, zone. So, naturally they fall in love. The diverse character representation (Black, lesbian, Latino, plus size, Korean, etc.), witty dialogue, and overall themes surrounding love and dating were, in my opinion, very much on point. My only qualm in regards to the plot is that I felt there were several missed opportunities for tying up loose ends (mostly to do with secondary characters). Overall, The Proposal is a low-stress, light-hearted read, that pairs nicely with a pool-side holiday, or that mid-week glass of Pinot Grigio.


Lauren on the characters

The two main characters in The Proposal were both fantastic and very well written! First of all, Nikole is such a badass! She handled the entire situation with Fisher like a pro! I loved that she was so independent and did what she needed to do to protect herself. (Those self defence classes? Yes!) Second of all, Nikole had THE BEST friends. I would love to know more about Courtney and Dana (and Natalie too)! They were all such interesting characters. I would love to see their stories rounded out a more. Lastly, Carlos. (Need I say more?) He was so amazing. Reading about him with his family and friends was wonderful. Plus, I felt like him and Nik really balanced each other out. He was definitely swoon-worthy in my opinion. I mean, who doesn’t love a guy that cooks, is a paediatrician, sweet, and quick witted? Sign me up please! 

Iris on the romance

The Proposal is a sweet and funny love story about two people determined not to fall in love (but, of course, ends up doing anyway). I thought the story was enjoyable and its portrayal of romance felt surprisingly accurate and realistic. I loved how it was a friends first and romance later type of relationship (and how supportive Carlos was of Nik!). However, I felt like Nik and Carlos’ chemistry lacked a little something. Sure, they were great together and I was rooting for them, but something kept me from fully connecting with them as a couple. It might have to do with the third person writing, or with the fact that the ending felt rushed, but I wasn’t fully invested. All and all, the romance in The Proposal was very enjoyable, just not the most memorable to me.



Caoimh on her favourite scene

I have been racking my brain to try and come up with my favourite scene in The Proposal. It has been a struggle because there are just SO many to choose from! So, I decided to cheat a little and choose two! *Drumroll please* For Nik and Carlos it has to be their attempt to make enchiladas and the infamous sour cream face mask. From its horrifying application to it cracking and ending up all over the floor, it was just hilarious. Nik and Carlos’ laughter was contagious and I could not stop giggling as the entire situation unfolded. My second favourite scene is one between Nik, Courtney, and Dana. Specifically when they sign up for the boxing class. From them underestimating their own strength (and the strength of their trainer) and ending up loving it and feeling powerful. It was the ultimate girl empowerment stance!

  • Plot 75% 75%
  • Romance 70% 70%
  • Characters 90% 90%